Comment 373 for bug 332945

Revision history for this message
Sebastian Geiger (lanoxx) wrote : Re: [Bug 332945] Re: [Jaunty] Update Notifier icon would provide useful status information

I have to agree here. What will happen to programms like pidgin or
Skype. Can we not send them to the notification area any more? That
would be really disappointing. What other place will there be to have a
permanent place of putting apps that run in the background, if you
ultimately remove the notification completly?

Chauncellor wrote:
> MPT: Oh, goodie! Looks like we have a winner here. I'll be voting that
> idea up.... I hope it's implemented soon, it's exactly what I was
> thinking about!
>
> May I ask what the end result of the notification area is, then? It
> seems like the goal is ultimately to completely remove the notification
> area. What would you do with "dockable" programs like Thunderbird or
> Pidgin, then? Where would I send them?
>
> Also, at this point in time, it seems that you guys are set on never looking back into putting the notifications into the notification bar. I would like to plead on my knees that something be done with the in-your-face pop-up, pop-under, evasive, invisible, or-whatever-is-being-boiled-next method that ultimately invades and annoys the users and also does less of a good job of notifying. Never have I had a window that I couldn't minimize in Ubuntu, and I'm always thankful of that when I have to use this Windows machine to connect to dial-up. Please, for the love of everything good and green, do not decide that the computer knows what windows should and should not be minimized. Vincenzo Ciancia put it well when he said "Really, I am in front
> of my beloved Ubuntu but I hate a part of it."
>
> That said, perhaps the end result of this cleaning may very well be for
> the better of GNOME. I very vehemently disagree with this removal, but
> perhaps there will be some better method that would be very friendly to
> all. At the present, though, it's pretty much decided that it is not.
>