Comment 11 for bug 433207

Revision history for this message
Tralalalala (tralalalala) wrote :

You've fixed this bug by swapping both buttons. Now "Save As" is on the left side and "Close without Saving" is on the right side. In my opinion that's not the correct way of fixing the bug. The focus should be moved from the left button to the right button.

Having "Save As" on the left side and "Close without Saving" on the right side doesn't match the behavior of other Gnome applications. Look at Gedit. It has the "Close without Saving" button on the left and "Save As" on the right and the right button has the focus. Swapping these buttons will break Gnomes consistent behavior. Users expect the "Save As" button to be on the right side, just like in Gedit or the GIMP. Users are used to clicking the right button to save. If the buttons are swapped in Sound Recorder users will lose their work after instinctively clicking the right button.