Comment 40 for bug 392799

Revision history for this message
Lorenzo J. Lucchini (ljl) wrote :

I feel this is another proposal that creates a cure potentially worse than the disease.
People are already confused enough with IRC without having a bot telling them to join another one-off channel. I fear #ubuntu will become a place to discuss how to join other channels and why.

Besides, if we use a different channel for each conversation, how will that be different from a private query? Sure, other people *can in theory* join, if it's a channel, but that's unlikely to happen if a new channel is "spawned" for each help request - at least, #ubuntu-classroom is *one* channel. Are we prepared to make #ubuntu *officially* hand off support to individuals (who may, maliciously or not, give terrible advice) without so much as a chance for someone to see what's going on?