Comment 76 for bug 589485

Revision history for this message
In , Tfa7 (tfa7) wrote :

(In reply to comment #16)
> See http://pastebin.com/vtzyBK6e for #xorg-devel discussion about this.
Some comments:

> <ohsix> not a lot of people are bothered, since getting the per display dpi
> right is a hard problem, even if you can set it for one single monitor in
> particular, 'fixed' is handling some difference in dpi across displays,
> which doesn't happen in the toolkits or anything

Wrong. *I* am bothered, and *I* operate a few dual-monitor setup including those with different display DPI. That ohsix windows migrant would have a hard time telling me that forcing DPI to a semi-arbitrary value to follow the obsolete windows suit is right (and that it is worth breaking what used to work since last century).

> <ohsix> maybe you misunderstood me, i was telling you what's expected to do it

By whom? Those who smoked windows crack and a gazillion of tray notifiers?

Thanks but no thanks. I've seen enough weird video hardware (e.g. Acer V550 monitors reported those funny EDID values) but those are rather *exceptions* to be handled, and one can even automate that -- if a display has DPI less than e.g. 30 or higher than e.g. 300 (as of today) then it might be treated as a reason to fall back to default (96 is ok here) since those who operate special cases *can* be expected to know their ways around hi-res displays or display walls.

> <ohsix> any cobbled together thing where nobody really cares
> is going to miss details like that

This bastard should not continue to erode free software. *He* doesn't care.

Seems that Red Hat has hired too many dumb morons who took their windows habits and attitude there, see also http://people.freedesktop.org/~cbrill/dri-log/?channel=dri-devel&date=2012-12-13 /fedora -- and recall the F12 PackageKit saga of Richard Hughes "fame": https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=534047#c9

PS: just in case, I'm using and developing free software since 1998 and have done numerous migrations for people and companies. I know that care *is* crucial. Good luck to Xorg team with preserving that.