comics! does not show comics I want to see

Bug #480182 reported by pauljohn32
8
This bug affects 1 person
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
Awn Extras
Fix Released
Medium
Gabor Karsay

Bug Description

I was pretty happy with the old no longer maintained Dilbert comic applet. I'm using comics! and have some trouble, and when I complained about it in a forum here, Mark Lee suggested I formalize this as a bug. (https://answers.edge.launchpad.net/awn-extras/+question/87111)

I'm running this version of awn in Ubuntu 9.10

0.3.9.1~bzr1794-1.9.10

The comics! applet does let me read dilbert. However, I can't see any of the other comic strips. I've tested the "add" function and added an address for a new comic, such as:

http://www.gocomics.com/wizardofid/rss.pxml

Here's the part I can't figure out, though. I can add a feed and in the add panel, it does show the wizard of id comic of the day. It offers me two identical comic strips, actually, and offers me a choice between them. However, upon closing the configure tool, the wizard comic won't show. I just see comics! in the bubble.

I understand that Dilbert comic is no longer maintained and I truly appreciate the effort to provide comics!. I do not in any way want to be seen as critical. If the person who works on comics! can fix that, I think it would be more fun.

A couple of other features from the previous comic applet would be good. There was a handy thing where you could right click to choose the date of the comic to display and also it would prompt the applet to go and get it. Also, in that previous version, the comic would display in a slightly larger format. In comics!, I can expand the image, but it becomes blurry. It seems to me that comic used to actually download a larger pixmap from the source.

Well, so long, and thanks for all the fish.

Tags: applet comics
Revision history for this message
Mark Lee (malept) wrote :

@pauljohn32:
We have a policy of only having one issue per bug (as noted in the bug guidelines, which is a link to the wiki <http://wiki.awn-project.org/OmnibusBugReportPolicy>). If you could put your feature requests (at the end of your description) in separate bugs, that would be great.

tags: added: applet comics feature-request
Changed in awn-extras:
assignee: nobody → Moses Palmér (mosespalmer)
importance: Undecided → Wishlist
tags: removed: feature-request
Changed in awn-extras:
importance: Wishlist → Medium
Revision history for this message
Moses Palmér (mosespalmer) wrote : Re: [Bug 480182] Re: comics! does not show comics I want to see

Hi pauljohn,

The reason that you have to choose between two identical strips is
because of the way that the applet has to guess what part of the XML
feed actually contains the comic. For some comics, the link to image is
not even present in the feed, but you have to download an HTML page and
parse it.

Have you tried selecting both strips from the configuration program? If
one does not work, the other one might.

With the Comics! applet, it is possible to select the comic of a
different date. Simply right click on the comics, select "Go to" (the
actual wording of this menu item might differ; I use a Swedish version
of Gnome) and click on the date you want to read.

The ability of the Dilbert applet to download a higher resolution image
is unfortunately not present in Comics!. The RSS feed that the newer
applet uses only provides low resolution images.

tis 2009-11-10 klockan 18:48 +0000 skrev Mark Lee:
> @pauljohn32:
> We have a policy of only having one issue per bug (as noted in the bug guidelines, which is a link to the wiki <http://wiki.awn-project.org/OmnibusBugReportPolicy>). If you could put your feature requests (at the end of your description) in separate bugs, that would be great.
>
> ** Tags added: applet comics feature-request
>
> ** Changed in: awn-extras
> Importance: Undecided => Wishlist
>
> ** Changed in: awn-extras
> Assignee: (unassigned) => Moses Palmér (mosespalmer)
>
> ** Tags removed: feature-request
>
> ** Changed in: awn-extras
> Importance: Wishlist => Medium
>

onox (onox)
Changed in awn-extras:
assignee: Moses Palmér (mosespalmer) → Gabor Karsay (gabor-karsay)
Revision history for this message
Gabor Karsay (gabor-karsay) wrote :

This is fixed in rev. 1494 and available in the new testing PPA.

I refer to the main point of this bug report that some comics are not shown or can't be installed. Some of the preinstalled comics were outdated. Alas feeds are changing from time to time and the URL or image index has to be updated.

Adding new comics shoud have always worked. As Moses Palmér pointed out you may have to try both strips if the applet lets you choose between two. The applet previously didn't download the comic immediately after adding it, that's why it may have seemed that it didn't add it at all.

As Mark Lee already wrote the other points you made would be separate bugs. I'll close this particular bug report for the main point as it's in the title. The other things would be Wishlist items, they are currently not supported, like a higher resolution image (this needs general support in the applet and plugins for each website with highres images), different date chooser or date chooser for comics that are not provided as feeds.

Changed in awn-extras:
milestone: none → 0.4.2
status: New → Fix Committed
Povilas Kanapickas (p12)
Changed in awn-extras:
status: Fix Committed → Fix Released
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.